The Tuck Box Scone-cakes
Annually my parents would drive us up to Monterey and Carmel for an extended weekend. My father loved Monterey, having been stationed at Fort Ord as a young man, he had all kinds of fond youthful memories of the place. We would stay at a motel near the freeway with a pool. My sister and I could have stayed at the pool with periodic visits to the vending and ice machines and been perfectly happy for the whole weekend, but Monterey and Carmel had more to offer( according to our parents). The Monterey Bay Aquarium was not there at the time, Cannery Row was a street of T-shirt shops and derelict old cannery buildings of which my dad had fond memories canning fish in the late forties, with dark skinned beauties of Italian decent.
My dad always made us stop in front of Ed Rickets old apartment, boarded up and empty. My dad would quote from Cannery Row and tell us tales of “Doc” as he was called in the book.
“Doc never trusted a woman with thin lips,” my dad would say. I would always feel my lips and wonder if I was trustworthy. Only eleven I knew that I had time for my lips to fill out, if they were too thin, what was too thin? How were lips tied to being trustworthy anyway?
The most memorable parts of these weekends I can recall are the hours in the pool pretending to be a synchronized swimmer and breakfast at the Tuck Box.
The Tuck Box is still on Dolores Street in Carmel. It is a cute building made to look like a house that Snow White and the seven dwarves might live in. It has window boxes spilling red geraniums, and leaded windows dripping their age and twisting the morning light into kaleidoscope colors and shapes as people walked by. The Tuck Box serves only breakfast and lunch.
We never went there for lunch. We were there for the scones and jam. Yellow wedges of fluffy cake like scones we slathered with homemade ollalieberry jam that we dug out of small glass containers with silver spoons. My sister and I always ordered hot tea that we dumped copious amounts of milk and sugar into. It was a magical place for us. We pretended we were somewhere far away, in England maybe or somewhere else we had never been, but must be like this, pretty and small, old and delicious.
I do not know how they make these scones. I know that they add yellow food coloring. Years later when I visited the place, a waitress slipped that tidbit of information to me. She said, “We tried to make them without the yellow food coloring and people complained that they just weren’t the same.” I have scoured cook books for a recipe and have come fairly close, but as far as I can tell they are a Scottish scone batter, made more like a cake, baked in a cast iron skillet. They are they served warm, cut into cake-like wedges.
I walked by the Tuck Box yesterday with a friend. “ I like that place,” I said as we passed.
She nodded and said “Yea, we ate there once, it was just okay.”
I didn’t say anymore. I knew that she must have ordered wrong. She hadn’t had the scones. Maybe she just went for the simple eggs and toast breakfast. The Tuck Box is all about the scones I nodded to myself with a knowing confidence.
I have taken my husband and both my children on pilgrimages to the Tuck Box. They enjoyed the scones, jam and tea. I can’t understand why they don’t have the same feeling of elation and longing to revisit the Tuck Box that I have. I love waiting in the straight backed chairs for a table, watching the waitresses pass the plates of warm scones and pots of tea onto the waiting tables of deserving diners. The constant motion of jam slathering and scone eating is a dance to observe.
I looked on the internet for the scone recipe. There were plenty of inquires and praises for and about the scones at the Tuck Box. I couldn’t find it. As my husband walked by he asked what I was looking for. I told him ,“The scone recipe from the Tuck Box.”
“Oh those,” he said , as if he had forgotten about them. How could he?
“Those are just a cornbread recipe made in a skillet without the cornmeal. They just keep baking them off and serving them hot. They wouldn’t be as good cold you know. It is all in the presentation of the warm, freshly baked corn-less cornbread, slathered with butter and then served with that ollalieberry jam.” He continued upstairs to finish what he was doing.
I was struck dumb, he was right. How had I never figured that out? I pulled out my box of Albers Cornmeal and read the recipe.
Today I baked a cake pan (not a skillet) of corn-less cornbread with yellow food coloring. Bingo, I had done it. I pulled them out of the oven and brushed a big spoonful of butter on the top and then opened a jar of my homemade ollalieberry jam. I cut a wedge out of the “scone-cake” and applied the jam. It was good, very good. I decided that I could reduce the salt by half and the rest was just as I remembered it. Funny how there was really was no mystery to the scones at all, except for figuring out that it wasn’t really a scone recipe.

The Tuck Box was and is a simple place making simple food, replicated over and over thousands of times; repeated, synchronized perfectly.
I wiped the jam off my mouth after eating the wedge of scone-cake today. I still don’t think my lips are thin, although they are not the full glamourous lips of the fashion magazines of today. I know that I am trustworthy, though I did just sleuth out and blog the mystery of the Tuck Box scones. Maybe they are a bit thin.
Scone-cakes
Adapted from Albers Corn Bread
- 2 cups all purpose flour
- 1/4 cup granulated sugar
- 1 TB baking powder
- 1/2 teas salt
- 1 cup milk
- 1/3 cup vegetable oil
- 1 large egg
- 1 teas vanilla
Combine all the ingredients, whisk together.
Pour into a greased 9” cake pan.
Bake at 400 F for 20 minutes.






